Half Life 1 vs Half Life 2

[sphinx]

Many people say half life 1 was better than half life 2. Some say the exact opposite. What do you guys have to say ? Which is better ?

[etali]

If you had to push me I'd say Half Life 1 - at least that was innovative-ish.

I didn't really like either that much though - they're both far too over-rated IMO. Half life 2 is the worst of the two though - theres more to a game than graphics and malleable terrain.

[Cobalt]

Half Life was a groundbreaking game, and changed the FPS genre forever. Although it looks blocky now, it was a fantastic tribute to the power of 3D graphics in its time. The gameplay was unique and immersive, and there was adequate challenge and diversity to keep things interesting.

Although Half Life 2 looks fantastic and is by no means a bad game, it didn't quite have the same effect as its former, plus it didn't spawn Counter-Strike

[undertone]

half life 2 could never have been better then its original. the original had something magical about it. maybe it was back mesa, maybe it was the story. half life 2 could never top that.

half life 1 was much more fun to play, and i cant wait for Black Mesa (hl2 mod thats recreating everything in hl1 on the source engine).

[deadloader]

yeah the story and the whole areas and what not, that was so much better than hl2, i would like to see the outcome of hl3, but it seems they're dragging out hl2 when it's really quite shit, episode 1 eat your heart out

[DixieGregory]

half life 1 is best but half life 2 is better then other

[zach tyrl]

I choose Half Life 2 since it was the one I played first, I can see Half Life is an awesome game, but it just feels odd playing it after HL2. I had the same problem with trying out FFVII after playing FFX first.

[Kathy44]

yup guys, half life 1 is very interesting game, I love to play it.

[OliverP]

Half life 2 is very interesting game, I really love to play it, However, half life 1 is no more interesting game. (This is my personal opinion-)

[monkey99]

Halo forever!!!